by CWK
I. Hypocritical Hypocrites
The popular definition of "hypocrite" is: "doing one thing and saying
another.” Hypocrisy is, then, a crossroads of words and deeds. This definition has worked its way into the unconscious American dictionary. "Saying one thing, doing another." This is a cliché, something you hear in the streets, again and again.
This definition is both
incorrect and dangerous.
Why?
1) It focuses our attention only on externals.
It never deals with the heart. Actually, hypocrisy goes deeper than our deeds and our words. It is a condition of our hearts. A person could conceivably say one thing, and do the same thing: especially if that person is careful with what they say. Many people say and do all the right things, and yet remain hypocrites.
2) This definition leaves sincere people feeling guilty.
Striving for the good, even telling others to strive for the good, is in itself good. Indeed, it would be better for some men to "say one thing, and do another." Most men live somewhat better than their worst principles, or their most outrageous boasts. Thank God. At the same time, all men live somewhat worse than their best principles. Any person who endeavors after a high and noble life will fall short, "We all fall short in many ways (James 3:2)." We have all come woefully short of who we should be, who we might have been, "All have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God (Romans 3:23)." None of us can claim perfection, but we should still, "strive, seek, find, and not yield." We may not have perfection, but we should have a God-ward direction: a life bent toward goodness and God.
Samuel Johnson: Nothing is more unjust, however common, than to charge with hypocrisy him that expresses zeal for those virtues which he neglects to practice; since he may be sincerely convinced of the advantages of conquering his passions, without having yet obtained the victory…
Defining hypocrisy as, "Saying one thing and doing another,” is bound to leave people feeling guilty, whilst encouraging them make their words and deeds consistent. It drives them to spiff up their external behavior. Defining hypocrisy thus drives people to hypocrisy.
3) This definition leaves self-righteous people gloating.
There's a reason this is the popular, we might say worldly, definition. This definition makes the worldly man feel comfortable in a state of superiority. This definition is flung from the rafters by righteous people onto the heads of bumblers below. It is used as a leveler, "You are no better than me." However, the moment I say that, I am claiming to be better than you. I am your judge. Thus, he who defines hypocrisy as saying one thing, doing another, is at the moment being a hypocrite.
Further, how, and from where this definition is hoisted onto the masses. It is often said by the irreligious, from rooftops, while they look down on poor, struggling Christians. There is an heir of self-righteousness, judgmentalism – aye, hypocrisy – in such a definition.
4) The definition is man-centered.
This definition of hypocrisy does not mention God. It makes hypocrisy something that can be judged by men, with myself – a man – the judge. We are not even qualified to judge ourselves – don't we often feel confused by our own actions? Unsure of our motives? How, then, can we ascend up to heaven and pronounce justice on other men?
The other problem with the pop definition of hypocrisy: It makes the opinions of man the final standard. This instinct to prize the opinion of man is in reality the root of true hypocrisy. So,once again, this false definition of hypocrisy lead us into true hypocrisy.
II. True Hypocrites
Our word "hypocrite" comes from the Greek, hypokrites = originally, a theatrical actor.
This word is used frequently in Matthew: Mt. 6.2, 6,
16; 7.5; 15.7; 22.18; 23.4, etc.; 24.51). In the LXX, it is a term for the godless
To understand hypocrisy, we need to meditate on what a theater actor does. Fundamentally, an actor is ‘acting,’ i.e. not his/her true self; they are acting like someone they are not, playing a role. Thus, there is always an element of unreality. Also, an actor is there to entertain; an actor is focused on pleasing the human audience. Thus, actors are known for ostentation, showmanship.
The hypocrite is a person who lives without God, as if there were no God, for the praise of man. All the marks of hypocrisy flow from the God-less life: ostentation; dissonance between deed/heart; focus on external to the neglect of internal; focus on silly 'little things,' to the neglect of genuinely important things.
A hypocrite is, “a person whose conduct is not determined by God and is thus ‘godless' (Giesen, upokrisis)."
A hypocrite is one, “whose concerns with legal observance were not rooted in the love of God or in a commitment to justice (Lk. 11.42; cf. 10.25-37) (Joel Green, NICNT, Luke, 480).”
The correct definition of hypocrisy: living without God.
Thomas Fuller: A hypocrite is in himself both the archer and the mark, in all actions shooting at his own praise or profit.
By "without God," I mean 1) In independence from God, 2) outside His Grace, 3) as if God did not exist, 4) As if God was blind, and incapable of judging, 5) As if there were no God.
These religious show-offs are “actors” in that they aim to
impress others, but at the same time their behavior demonstrates how far they
are out of touch with God’s understanding of “righteousness” (France, NICNT, Matthew, 237).
(Yeast is a metaphor for that which has) penetrating
power... corrupting influence... The Pharisaic mind-set is represented as a
contaminant with potential to invade even the company of Jesus’ followers.
Pushing the metaphor further, Jesus also builds on the secretive nature of
yeast, the work of which is concealed at first, apparent later (Lk. 12.2-3)...
Such yeast must be avoided, Jesus warns, because nothing will remain hidden...
(‘will be manifest’ could mean)... First... the inner dispositions of people
are evident in their outward behavior (cf. Lk. 8.17; 11.33-36; 6.43-45)....Second,
and more at home in this co-text, the true constitution of a disciple will come
to light in the experience of persecution – and, as is becoming more and more
clear, persecution is the lot of those who are faithful to God in the midst of
an evil generation (6.22-23, 27-28). Third, Jesus’ caution that all will be
made manifest may be read as an eschatological warning: Conversation presumed
to be secret now will become public then (Joel Green, NICNT, Luke, 480-481).
(Scribes and Pharisees) are accused of having missed the
point of true religion especially by focusing on minutiae and externals instead
of on the essentials of the sort of life God really desires. This tragically
distorted perspective has become so entrenched that it has made them enemies of
God’s true messengers (Mt. 23.29-36) (R.T. France, NICNT, Matthew, 869).”
So, the contradiction of hypocrisy is NOT between word and deed, but between external and internal. Actually, the practice of hypocrites appears perfect, beautiful, spotless – it is their heart which is ugly (Mt. 23.27-28).
“They make their phylacteries
broad, and enlarge the borders of their garments... All their works they do to be seen by men (Mt. 23.4-5).”
“They appear outward beautiful, but are within full of dead
bones, and of all uncleanness... (they) appear righteous to men, but within are
full of hypocrisy and iniquity (Mt. 23.27-28).”
The Characteristics of Hypocrisy
1. Focusing on externals to neglect of internal.
2. Putting on a show.
3. Cleaning the outside of cup, and neglecting inside; putting
a band-aid on a bullet wound.
4. Doing works as a public show ‘to be seen by men,’ i.e. practical
atheism, as if humans were the only audience.
5. Living like image is everything; putting on costumes to
impress.
6. Hunger for honorific titles.
7. Obsession with external items (in our day = clothing, tattoos,
necklaces, bracelets, etc.) to show and identify piety.
8. Focus on minutiae of law-keeping, while neglecting true
godly priorities.
Questions, For Self-Examination, to Diagnose Hypocrisy
1) Is our focus on external or internal?
2) Do we find ourselves ‘putting on a show’ around men, hoping they see us and take note of what good people we are?
3) Do we long for praise of God, or praise of men? Who is the real ‘audience’ of our lives? Are we more concerned what man thinks, or what God thinks?
4) Is there an inconsistency between who people think we are and who we actually are?
5) Are we more concerned with our image than with heart holiness?
6) Are we honest with people about our failings, faults, frailty?
7) Are we obsessed with external trappings of religiosity: looking good at Church, having the ‘right’ Bible, being a well-known teacher, looking like the perfect Christian family, wearing Christian apparel, trinkets (see Mt. 23.5-6)?
8) Are we more concerned with style, or substance?
9) When we pray, fast, give, sing, preach... who are we doing these things for? Who are we most concerned about? God? Man?
10) Would our lives bear out the reality, "God will bring every deed into judgment, including every hidden thing, whether it is good or evil (Ecclesiastes 12:14).
V. The Characteristics of Sincerity
Looking Out Versus Looking UP, and WITHIN.
The hypocrite is always looking OUT, at other men; the godly man is looking UP, at God, and WITHIN, at HIMSELF. The godly man is aware of his failing because he is aware of God, and himself. Further, the godly man is more concerned about
the sin in me than
the sin in you.
We're quick to call other's hypocrites; we betray ourselves, and our self-righteousness, when we do so. We need to be aware just how powerful examples of hypocrisy are, and just how easily
we ourselves fall into a lifestyle of hypocrisy. Jesus gives the warning about hypocrisy in Luke 12:1 to his disciples,
"...
he began to say to his disciples first, “Beware of the leaven of the Pharisees,which is hypocrisy (Luke 12.1-3; cf. Mt. 23.1, "to his disciples")."
Jesus is concerned about hypocrites, but he is also concerned about his disciples. He warns us. Why? Because we need it, and if we don’t heed it, we are in danger of hypocrisy. Consider your own danger of being hypocrites, the Lord Jesus is saying. It is amazing of hypocrisy can creep into the places we least expect it.
Thomas Shephard, the American puritan, wrote in his journal:
After my Wednesday sermon I saw the towering pride of my heart in all I did. As soon as I had done any public work my wicked heart would immediately look (to see) whether men praised me or no. Hereupon I saw my incurable vileness to make the opinions of passing men my rule and my reward in doing the work of the everlasting God.
The Characteristics of Sincerity
1. Contra hiding sin, and pretending to be perfect, confessing sin honestly in high-definition (1 John 1.9). The most holy men often seem least holy because they are honest about their sin.
2. More concerned about God’s opinion than man’s – doing
acts of righteousness toward God, to be seen by Him (Mt. 23.5).
3. Loving God’s law in the heart, even if failing in
practice (Romans 7.22-25).
4. Contra "keeping up appearances," focus on the inner, hidden person (Mt. 23.26).
5. Living before God, knowing that He sees and knows all –
down to heart motives, and that on the judgment day he will bring every last deed into judgment, including
‘every hidden thing – whether good or evil (Eccl. 12.13-14).” In short, doing
everything before the Lord, to the Lord, for His glory (1 Cor. 11.33).
VI. What About Religious Hypocrites?
Sincere followers of Christ need to be ready: Unbelievers are prone to point out the faults of Christians with such slanders as, "All these Christians are sinners just like me. Just a bunch of hypocrites." Several responses can/should be made.
1) The sins of the church prove one of the main teachings found within the Church, "We all fall short in many ways (James 3:2)." "The sins of the Church are one of the doctrines of the Church (Chesterton)." Consider: some of our greatest saints have been great sinners (David; Peter).
Carlyle said that men were mostly fools. Christianity, with a surer and more reverent realism, says that they are all fools. This doctrine is sometimes called the doctrine of original sin. It may also be described as the doctrine of the equality of men. But the essential point of it is merely this, that whatever primary and far-reaching moral dangers affect any man, affect all men. All men can be criminals, if tempted; all men can be heroes, if inspired (G.K. Chesteron, Heretics, Chapter XII, "Paganism and Mr. Lowes Dickinson").
So, you are pointing out that even the supposedly best men sin? We agree. In fact, Christians of all people have constantly reminded the world how wretchedly they fail. This sense of unworthiness is what qualifies them: Jesus came to seek and save the lost, the sinners, the bad people: "I came to seek and save that which was lost (Luke 19.10);" "Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners, of whom I am the chief (1 Tim. 1.15)."
2) Related to response 1, Christians believe, not in themselves, but the grace of God in Christ, not in salvation by works, but salvation by God's grace.
There is no reason for God's love in any man, if there is none in you, you are not worse off than the best of men, for there is none in them; the grace and love of God can come as freely to you as they can to those that have long been seeking them, for "I am found of them that sought me not."- Charles Spurgeon, Grace Abounding.
3) Read Matthew 23. Jesus hated hypocrisy more than you: Jesus is the great hero attacking the fortress of hypocrisy across human history. No one said as many severe things to hypocrites as he did; indeed, no one was qualified as he was to say such things. He was sinless; he could see the human heart. He hated hypocrisy, on earth, and breathed fire against it; he will hate it hereafter, with hell-fire.
4) If the Church is so bad, why don't you join it, and show everyone how to live.
5) Are you really different than those you attack as hypocrites? Isn't you own life in discord? Don't you also fail to be who you would like to be? Are you, really, any better? Are you fit to judge people? Can you see down into the human heart? Isn't God the final judge? Also, Remember, "The same standard by which you judge others, that standard will be applied to you (Mt. 7:2)."
6) Hypocrisy is the opposite of true Christianity. It is indeed ugly: ugly, because it is false. Thus, we should not discard true religion, we should discard false religion.
Appendix A: Mt. 23.1-39: Notes
1a. What Hypocrisy IS
It is…
v. 27-28 “Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! For you
are like whitewashed tombs, which outwardly
appear beautiful, but within are full of dead people's bones
and all uncleanness. So you also
outwardly appear righteous to others, but within you are full of hypocrisy
and lawlessness.
greek, hypokrites
= taken from ACTOR: plays part i.e. not his/her true self; they are acting like
someone they are not, playing a role.
Common definition of hypocrite: one who says one thing, but does another. However, the practice (THE DOING) of
hypocrites appears beautiful: v. 27.
Hypocrisy = not so much: word v. deed BUT word v. heart.
There's a DISHARMONY between: Outward v. Inward; External v. Internal;
Appearance v. Reality
Mt. 15.7-9: You hypocrites… This people honors me with
their lips; But their heart is far from me.
1b. Hypocrisy: What It’s Not
Not simply saying one thing, doing another. Recognizing
something is good/right – then falling short.
Romans 7.19, 22: For I do not do the good I want, but the
evil I do not want is what I keep on doing… For I delight in the law of God, in
my inner being.
2. How -- How do hypocrites act?
v. 5: They do all their deeds to be seen by men…calculated:
religious showboater/showmanship.
Spurgeon: "When
you see a man with a great deal of religion displayed in his shop window, you
may depend upon it, he keeps a very small stock of it within."
3. Where -- Where is focus of hypocrite?
v. 6: they love
the place of honor at feasts and the
best seats in the synagogues…
The hypocrite is NOT concerned about the Glory of God or Love of Neighbor. We say, "All roads lead to Rome. For the hypocrite, "All roads lead to SELF."
4. Who -- Who is the audience of hypocrite?
Hypocrite: audience = man. For godly man, audience = God.
v. 5ff: They do all their deeds to be seen by men
Appendix B: More Self-Examination Questions
1) APPEARANCES 1: Do we care more about appearances – or reality? Substance – or,
style?
Are our interactions with others calculated to falsely
impress? to get others to think highly of us? A godly man would rather others think too lowly of him than too highly.
2) APPEARANCES 2: Are we more concerned about doing right, or being right?
Missionary questionnaire: “Are you quick to
admit you are wrong and ask forgiveness? Would those who know you best agree
with your answer?”
Fathers, your job is not just to LOOK GOOD. Christian Leaders, what does it mean to be a Christian leader?
Lead in repentance?
How do we respond when someone confronts us with sin in our lives? Anger? Thankfulness?
Spurgeon received sermon corrections year after year from an anonymous source. When he heard the man was moving to another town, he said, "I only wish had chance to thank him."
3) APPEARANCES 3: Am I genuine with others? About my sins? My
weaknesses? My struggles? What kind of prayer requests am I offering?
4) APEARANCES 4: Do we deal with sin in relationships? Real change, and forgiveness. Or (because we don't want to offend anyone) just gloss it
over in sinful peace?
4) Why? Why do we give ...Time? Money? So others THINK we're great? Or, for the Love for God?
Mt. 23.5 They do all their deeds to be seen by others. For they make their phylacteries broad and their fringes long, 6 and they love the place of honor at feasts and the best seats in the synagogues 7 and greetings in the marketplaces and being called rabbi by others.
Augustine:
Moral character is assessed not
by what a man knows but by
what he loves.
Edwards: God does not accept the hand without the heart.
5) Do I focus on the heart? Or, the show?
From Tedd Tripp, on parenting,
Shepherding a Child’s
Heart:
There are many bribes and punishments that are attempts to
manipulate behavior without touching the heart. "First clean the inside of
the cup" Jesus said. Outward behavior is not the problem; it is the heart…
The world has nowhere else to go except to (violent) constraint and
(superficial) change. We can go to the God who changes the heart.